Skip to content
Wednesday, November 18, 2026 Independent editorial reviews. No user ratings, no paid scores.
Software & AppsDesign & Creative Tools

Core dna Research Review: Honest AI Shopping Insights

A revealing study showing ChatGPT misquoted prices on 13 of 38 Black Friday product recommendations, highlighting AI's reliability gaps.

Share
Core dna Black Friday Price Test

As shoppers increasingly turn to AI tools for deal-hunting, a new study from eCommerce platform Core dna reveals a sobering reality: ChatGPT misquoted prices on about a third of its Black Friday product recommendations. The research, conducted on November 4, 2026, tested 20 popular products twice each and found that 13 of 38 checkable retailer recommendations had incorrect prices.

Core dna’s team asked ChatGPT, “Where is the cheapest place to buy the [product] in the US right now?” for items like the KitchenAid Artisan stand mixer, Garmin Forerunner 265, and JBL Flip 7 speaker. Each query was made from a New York connection on a free account with memory off. The results are a must-read for anyone planning to rely on AI for holiday shopping.

What is the Core dna Black Friday Price Test?

This is an independent, transparent study that evaluates how accurately ChatGPT quotes current retailer prices for popular Black Friday products. Core dna, an eCommerce platform founded in Australia in 2004, designed the test to help consumers understand AI’s reliability—and to help retailers fix issues before the biggest shopping day of the year.

The methodology is clear: researchers checked every recommended store’s own website on the same day, using New York and Brooklyn ZIP codes. A price was counted as correct only if it was within one dollar of the store’s own price for the exact item, sold directly by the store. Marketplace sellers, refurbished units, and card offers were considered wrong.

What stands out

Thirteen wrong prices out of 38

ChatGPT quoted the wrong price 13 times—seven were too low, two too high, and four were marketplace seller prices presented as the store’s own. For instance, it sent shoppers to Best Buy for a KitchenAid Artisan at $219.99, but Best Buy was actually charging $349.99.

Retailers’ own sites contributed to errors

Almost half of the wrong prices (six) started on the retailers’ own websites. Marketplace listings and different product SKUs on the same page confused ChatGPT, which picked up the wrong number.

Ads sometimes showed the truth

In two cases, Best Buy’s ad displayed the correct price directly under an answer that recommended a price the store wasn’t charging. This highlights the disconnect between AI answers and sponsored content.

Asking again changes the answer

For 11 of the 20 products, the second query returned a different store or price. This inconsistency means shoppers can’t trust a single answer.

Target was consistently overlooked

Target was named in 25 answers but never recommended as the cheapest, often because its price was just one cent above the winning store.

Who it’s for

This study is invaluable for online shoppers who use AI to find deals, especially during high-stakes events like Black Friday. It’s also crucial for retailers, eCommerce managers, and digital marketers who want to understand how their product pages appear in AI-generated answers.

Content creators and SEO professionals will find the research useful for optimizing product data to avoid being misrepresented by AI tools. The study serves as a wake-up call for anyone who assumes AI chatbots are always accurate.

What makes it worth considering

The Core dna test is rigorous and transparent—the full methodology, all 40 answers, and screenshots are publicly available. The research was conducted in a controlled manner, with new chats and memory off, ensuring reproducibility.

It also provides actionable insights: retailers can check how their top products appear in ChatGPT and fix misleading listings before Black Friday. The study’s timing, just weeks before the biggest shopping day of the year, makes it especially timely.

Verdict

An essential, eye-opening study that every online shopper and retailer should read before Black Friday. It reveals critical gaps in AI price accuracy and offers a clear path for improvement.

Frequently asked questions

20 popular Black Friday products were tested twice each, for 40 total answers.

13 out of 38 checkable recommendations had wrong prices.

Marketplace sellers, refurbished items, and old deal prices from trackers.

No, ads ran separately; in two cases the ad showed the correct price under a wrong answer.

Best Buy and Walmart had marketplace seller prices quoted as their own.

Yes, during Black Friday week, as noted in the study.

At coredna.com/blogs/chatgpt-black-friday-prices-us with screenshots.