Rigney Law Review: Experienced Criminal Defense in Indianapolis

Facing a criminal charge is disorienting even for people who have never been near a courtroom, and the first decision, who to call, often matters as much as anything that happens afterward. Rigney Law LLC built its Indianapolis practice specifically around that moment, offering a free, no-pressure consultation so clients can understand their situation before deciding how to proceed.

What sets the firm apart is perspective: its founders spent years as Marion County deputy prosecutors before moving to the defense side, giving them a working knowledge of how the other side builds a case and where its weaknesses tend to show up.

What is Rigney Law LLC?

Rigney Law LLC is a criminal defense firm based in Indianapolis, founded by attorneys Jake and Kassi Rigney. Between them, the founders bring more than 30 years of combined legal experience, including time spent as Marion County deputy prosecutors, a background that shapes how the firm approaches case strategy, plea negotiations and trial preparation alike.

Also worth a look: LawZen Review: A Simpler Way to Find a Lawyer in Canada and Fox & Moghul Review: Trusted Business and Real Estate Counsel.

The firm serves Marion County and the broader central Indiana area, handling everything from misdemeanor charges to serious felonies, and it is active in public legal education as well, discussing Indiana court procedure and appellate decisions through its own long-running podcast.

Key features

Broad criminal defense coverage

The firm handles OWI/DUI defense, including breath and blood test challenges and license suspension issues, alongside drug crime cases ranging from simple possession to distribution charges.

Gun crime and violent felony representation

Rigney Law defends clients facing unlicensed carry, prohibited possession and firearm enhancement charges, as well as serious violent felonies including robbery, burglary, battery and domestic violence cases.

Beyond the courtroom

The practice also handles civil asset forfeiture challenges, expungement petitions to seal past arrests and convictions, license rehabilitation for driver’s license reinstatement, and representation at parole board hearings.

A free, honest first conversation

Prospective clients can discuss their charges and options with an attorney at no cost and with no obligation to retain the firm, lowering the barrier to getting real information early.

Accessible, around-the-clock support

The firm notes availability around the clock and offers Spanish-language services, making it easier for clients to reach someone quickly after an arrest regardless of when it happens.

Public legal education

The firm’s attorneys also discuss Indiana appellate decisions, courtroom procedure and emerging legal issues through long-running, unscripted audio episodes, covering topics such as license plate surveillance and recent court rulings. For prospective clients, that body of public commentary doubles as a way to get a feel for how the attorneys think about a case before ever sitting down for a consultation, which is a level of transparency most criminal defense firms don’t offer.

Who it’s for

Rigney Law is built for anyone facing a misdemeanor or felony charge in Indianapolis and the surrounding counties, as well as people currently under criminal investigation who want to understand their exposure before charges are even filed. The firm’s range, from DUI and drug charges through violent felonies and federal prosecutions, means clients don’t need to find a new firm if a case’s complexity shifts partway through. Families supporting a loved one through a criminal matter are also a natural audience, since the free consultation gives them a clear, judgment-free way to understand what comes next. The firm’s Spanish-language services and around-the-clock availability also make it a practical option for clients who need to reach an attorney outside standard business hours, such as shortly after an arrest or over a weekend, when the first 24 to 48 hours of a case can meaningfully affect how it unfolds.

What makes it worth considering

The former-prosecutor background is the firm’s clearest differentiator: attorneys who spent years deciding which cases to pursue and how aggressively to pursue them bring a genuinely different lens to building a defense than attorneys who have only worked one side of the aisle. Combined with a free initial consultation and broad coverage across case types, that experience gives clients a realistic, informed starting point rather than a sales pitch. The firm’s willingness to explain Indiana court procedure publicly, through long-form discussion of real appellate decisions and courtroom practice, also reflects a level of transparency that’s uncommon in criminal defense marketing. For clients weighing whether to fight a charge, negotiate a plea, or pursue post-conviction relief like expungement, having attorneys who have personally sat on the prosecution side of each of those decisions is a genuine advantage, not just a line in a biography. That perspective tends to show up in small but meaningful ways, from how a case is framed in early negotiations to which procedural issues get flagged before they become missed opportunities later in the process.

Verdict

Rigney Law combines former-prosecutor insight with wide-ranging case experience and a genuinely free, no-obligation consultation, making it a solid first call for anyone facing criminal charges in central Indiana. Its depth across case types means clients can stick with one firm as a case evolves. Between the founders’ prosecutorial background, round-the-clock accessibility and a public commitment to explaining how Indiana’s courts actually work, Rigney Law offers the kind of informed, steady guidance that matters most in the disorienting first hours after an arrest, and that makes it a firm worth having on speed dial well before it’s ever needed.